A bold choice in his career, Keegan accepted the lead role in Greg Berlanti's critically acclaimed "The Broken Hearts Club" showing a more vulnerable side as the "Newbie." The film won "Best Picture" that year at the "GLAAD Awards." Expanding his range in 2009, Keegan made his theatrical stage debut in the provocative award winning play, "He Asked For It." Keegan stepped on stage as "Rigby", a character tackling the emotional issues of being HIV Positive in a modern-day society. In 2010 Keegan jumped into the cockpit as "Strayger", a drug smuggling pilot in the high-octane action film, "Kill Speed". Innovative camera technology allowed the adrenaline-driven actor to give his performance while doing aeronautical stunts in mid flight.
 

Alongside William Sadler and John Heard, Keegan most recently took on a darker role as a sadistic and sociopathic vampire, "Blake", in the film "Living Among Us", scheduled for release in late 2014..